Help! Someone Filed a False Insurance Claim Against Me

Schedule a Free Consultation
Written by: Benton Accident & Injury Lawyers Last Updated : May 14, 2024

Help! Someone Filed a False Insurance Claim Against Me image

Feeling shocked and frustrated is natural if someone files a false insurance claim against you. False car accident claims are incredibly stressful and frightening. At Benton Accident & Injury Lawyers, our compassionate legal team understands your difficult situation. We help you understand your rights and options during this trying time.

How Common Are False Insurance Claims?

False insurance claims against innocent drivers occur more frequently than you might think. Scammers often stage fake accidents to collect money from insurance companies by filing a false claim. They may claim you caused a collision that never actually happened. Or they may accuse you of fleeing the scene of an accident you did not even know occurred.

Another common scam involves a con artist waving an innocent driver ahead at an intersection, then purposely crashing into their vehicle and blaming them for the accident. The scammer may even have a group of “witnesses” ready to back up their false story to the police and insurance companies.

First Steps After a False Claim

First, take a deep breath and try to remain as calm as possible. You will get through this troubling experience. Don’t think about how someone filed a false insurance claim against you — the most crucial step is to consult an experienced attorney immediately.

Avoid Confronting the Scammer Directly

When you have a false car insurance claim made against you, your initial instinct may be to contact the scammer and demand they recant their accusations or to mediate out of court and/or ask for a settlement. However, this is unwise and could backfire. Engaging with the fraudster directly could aggravate the situation and make matters worse. Let your lawyer handle all interactions and communications on your behalf.

Disputing the False Claim with Your Insurer

Your attorney can communicate with your insurance company to dispute the fraudulent claim. Gather evidence and provide your lawyer with any evidence you have that the alleged accident never happened or transpired differently than the scammer claims. This may include photographs of your undamaged vehicle, security camera footage of the supposed accident location, or alibis proving you were somewhere else when the scammer says the incident occurred.

Read more: What Not to Say to an Insurance Adjuster

Spotting the Red Flags of Fraud

False accident claims often unravel when scrutinized closely. When an insurance company investigates the accusation, they may find the vehicle damage does not match the scammer’s story. Or the date and location the fraudster provides for the accident may not line up. Your attorney can highlight these discrepancies to help dismiss the false claim.

Your lawyer may need a skilled investigator to dig deeper into the fraud in certain cases. The investigator can analyze the accident scene, research the other driver’s prior claims history, interview witnesses, and look for suspicious connections between the scammer and their alleged witnesses. The more evidence you have to combat the lies, the better.

Even when facing a false car insurance claim against you, honesty with your insurance company is crucial. Attempting to hide an accident that did happen, even if it genuinely was not your fault, will only cast doubt on your credibility. Your lawyer can present your truthful side of the story to your insurer clearly and persuasively.

Dealing with Police Inquiries

If someone made a false car insurance claim against you, law enforcement may contact you with questions about the alleged accident in the police reports. You have the right to remain silent, as your statements could be used against you. Have your attorney interact with the police to clear up any misconceptions and set the record straight.

When False Claims Lead to Lawsuits

Be aware that false accident claims can lead to full-blown insurance fraud lawsuits. The scammer may claim they suffered injuries in the fabricated accident and attempt to sue you for large sums. If you receive notice of a personal injury lawsuit related to an accident that never occurred, contact an attorney right away. Never ignore legal documents, as this could result in a default judgment against you.

An experienced car accident lawyer can spot the warning signs of a fraudulent personal injury claim and develop a strong legal strategy to defend you. Your attorney will know the most effective ways to expose the deception and protect your interests in court.

In a worst-case scenario, some innocent drivers have to fight liens on their vehicles, driver’s license suspensions, or even criminal charges after a false accident claim. If you are facing any of these serious consequences for a collision that was not your fault, you need aggressive legal representation immediately. The stakes are far too high to confront this situation alone.

You Need a Strong Legal Advocate

Help! Someone Filed a False Insurance Claim Against Me image 2

The car insurance fraud attorneys at Benton Accident & Injury Lawyers can help you take on this complex process and get your life back on track. We have the knowledge and experience to untangle the web of lies the scammer has created and protect your reputation. Our attorneys are skilled at thwarting fraudulent insurance and legal claims against innocent motorists like you.

Although you may feel helpless and alone when battling a false accident claim, you have powerful allies in your corner with the legal team at The Benton Accident & Injury Lawyers. We will manage every detail of your case with the utmost thoroughness and dedication to exposing the truth.

Defend Yourself

Do not let a scammer get away with tarnishing your driving record, lowering your insurance coverage, and increasing your insurance premiums through deceit. You are innocent and should not suffer because of someone else’s greed and dishonesty. Take immediate action to resolve this stressful ordeal by contacting a knowledgeable lawyer today.

If someone filed a false auto insurance claim against you, call Benton Accident & Injury Lawyers at (214) 777-7777 or reach out online for a free and confidential case evaluation. Our attorneys are available 24/7 to discuss your unique situation and explain how we can help you fight these false allegations. The sooner you have a strong legal advocate working for you, the better your chances of overcoming a fraudulent claim.

Trusting the exceptional legal team at Benton Accident & Injury Lawyers is the most effective way to fight back against fraudulent insurance tactics and get the justice you deserve. Call today to schedule your free consultation with a caring Dallas car accident attorney committed to defending your rights, reputation, and future. You do not have to face this difficult situation alone. Help is just a phone call away.

Related Posts:

What To Do After an Accident That Is Not Your Fault

Why Some Personal Injury Cases Go To Trial

What Do You Need To Do If Your Accident Report Is Incorrect

Ready to get the help you deserve? Call (214) 777-7777 or

Click Here to Email Us